Two cars on the same rows. The figures are all here, with their sources, so you can read them yourself and decide what matters.
| BMW 1 Series | BMW X5 | |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel (differs) | Petrol | Petrol, Diesel, Plug-in Hybrid |
| Model years (differs) | 2019-now | 2018-now |
| From (indicative) (differs) | € 37,900 | € 85,000 |
| Status | Available | Available |
| RatingsRating figures: higher is better (scale 0-100). What each category measures is explained on the methodology page. | ||
| Reliability (differs) | 72/100 | – |
| Efficiency (differs) | 69/100 | – |
| Practicality (differs) | 66/100 | – |
| Value retention (differs) | n/a | – |
| Sustainability (environmental impact) (differs) | 40/100 | – |
| Specifications | ||
| Body style (differs) | Hatchback | SUV |
| Power (hp) (differs) | 156 | 298 |
| 0–100 km/h (s) (differs) | 7.8 | 6.1 |
| Top speed (km/h) (differs) | 226 | 233 |
| Length (mm) (differs) | 4361 | 4935 |
| Width (mm) (differs) | 1800 | 2004 |
| Height (mm) (differs) | 1459 | 1765 |
| Kerb weight (kg) (differs) | 1500 | 2295 |
| Consumption WLTP (l/100km) (differs) | 6.1 | – |
| Max. towing weight, braked (kg) (differs) | 1500 | 3500 |
| Boot (l) (differs) | 380 | 650 |
| Seats | 5 | 5 |
| Doors | 5 | 5 |
OEM datasheets + RDW + ADAC (see methodology); rating and reference dates are listed per figure
A short write-up on each car, one paragraph apiece. We describe them on their own terms rather than picking a winner.
Profile · F40 (facelift 2024)
C-segment hatchback on the F40, front-wheel drive in the base since this generation. The 118i delivers about 156 hp from a petrol three-cylinder with 48V mild hybrid. WLTP around 6.1 l/100km (manufacturer figure, indicative); owners report 6.5-7.5 l/100km mixed (public forums, not measured by us).
Profile · G05 LCI (2023+)
Large SUV on the CLAR platform. 2023 facelift adds new headlights and curved display; PHEV xDrive50e offers around 100 km EV range (manufacturer figure, indicative).
Continue
+ Compare with another modelBoth cars are already filled in — just add a third to compare.
No tax or financial advice. Every figure shows its source and reference date. Always compare with an independent adviser and the official source. Source: OEM datasheets + RDW + ADAC (see methodology); rating and reference dates are listed per figure.